Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, 2012

Committee Blogs
Topic 1

Regulating Civilian Private Security Services

The CCPCJ is responsible for improving international crime prevention through effective and fair criminal enforcement. Recently, the committee has started to examine the role of civilian private security services (CPSS) in preventing crime and promoting community safety. CPSS are for-hire security forces that often have contracts with local, municipal, and national governments. As late as 2009, the first request for an ad-hoc session was passed and some member States have met to discuss their current policies. In its most recent session in 2011, the CCPCJ identified CPSS as a world trend in criminal enforcement. Governments working with private security services also fulfill the CCPCJ’s vision for increased public and private sector partnerships in crime prevention and criminal justice.

While many states have expressed positive sentiments for such partnerships, some member States have voiced problems with regulation, including non-compliance and corruption. Some states believed that as a private, profit-making entity working in the public sector, CPSS are not mainly concerned with crime prevention and instead, focus solely on profits. Also, the varying degrees of capabilities of CPSS in different member-states create barriers to increased cooperation between other security services. As a new phenomenon in crime prevention and criminal justice, CPSS lack basic structure and regulation for training standards, ethics, qualifications, and staffing. This topic will challenge delegates to apply existing international conventions and their respective country policies on CPSS to a wider, international context and work to develop this new form of criminal justice.

Topic 2

Youth and Crime in South America

According to the CCPCJ mandate, the committee is responsible for creating and improving the effectiveness and fairness of international criminal enforcement. Especially after the drafting of the Salvador Declaration at the Twelfth United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, the CCPCJ has shifted its focus to identifying contemporary criminal trends and introducing resolutions pertaining to such trends before crime occurrences increase. In this vein, the committee has already addressed a particular aspect of youth involvement in crime through the thematic discussion on the misuse of technology in the abuse and exploitation of children. The committee has not yet discussed the actual involvement of youth in transnational crime or transnational organized crime.

Currently, the level of governmental enforcement combating crime varies from country to country. Most countries do not have legal codes pertaining directly to children and often deal with child criminals on a case-by-case basis. This not only leads to a lack of consistency, but also a clear focus on enforcement, without prevention. While direct enforcement and treatment act as a short-term solution, a long-term solution must incorporate prevention of youth from engaging in a life of crime. Effective criminal justice should both prevent crime and treat current offenses. The case in South America provides an excellent example of youth involvement in transnational organized crime. With pervasive drug cartels operating across the continent, South American youth are exposed to crime—and often become participants—at a very early age. By focusing on this specific region, with varying levels of state development, delegates may create a model to be used elsewhere around the world. This topic will challenge delegates to take a realistic look at the problem and to plan for the needs of youth while enforcing international criminal standards. As teenagers with vastly different experiences than those of South American youth, delegates may nonetheless feel a connection to a very real problem facing their generation.
 

Resources
Downloads: 

 

Director, Ryan Youra

American University

 

Assistant Director, Sean Gilrain

University of Georgia
 

National High School Model United Nations | New York City, NY

2012 Committees